Media and Collective Identity

The Shawshank Redemption - Key Text Notes

The Shawshank Redemption
(Frank Darabont 1994)

Film Information
Directed by:  Frank Darabont
CAST
Andy Dufresne:  Tim Robbins
Ellis Boyd "Red" Redding:  Morgan Freeman
Warden Norton:  Bob Gunton
Captain Hadley:  Clancy Brown
Heywood:  William Sadler
Tommy:  Gil Bellows
Brooks:  James Whitmore
Boggs:  Mark Rolston

SYNOPSIS

After the murder of his wife, hotshot banker Andrew Dufresne is sent to Shawshank Prison, where the usual unpleasantness occurs. Over the years, he retains hope and eventually gains the respect of his fellow inmates, especially longtime convict "Red" Redding, a black marketeer, and becomes influential within the prison
Preferred Reading
The emotions the film aims to provoke in the spectator are very closely linked to the themes which drive the narrative:  Hope, injustice, friendship, fear, imprisonment and freedom, retribution.

Of all the emotions the spectator is manipulated to experience within the film as a whole the most prominent are:

Triumph - When Andy wins small victories such as on the rooftop or when he plays the music, the spectator is positioned to feel a sense of triumph.  When he finally escapes, that sense of triumph is magnified enormously.

Despair - There is much sadness within the film; Brooks' lonely death, Andy's wrongful imprisonment, the loss of hope in Red.

Satisfaction - There is so much injustice in the film that when justice is served or characters get some measure of revenge or retribution we feel it very strongly.  The warden being forced to kill himself is an excellent example.

Pity - The spectator is manipulated to feel great sympathy and pity for the characters.  The prisoners go through terrible experiences and have many of their human rights and dignities stripped from them.  Due to immersion, identification and representation we feel sorry for them.

Joy - The joy of Red and Andy's reunion as free men is the arguably one of the most affecting moments in the film.  It is certainly the most joyful.  There are other moments of joy too - the music scene and the rooftop scene as well as Andy's escape.

Injustice - Huge injustices take place in the film and the protagonists are almost constantly being abused, exploited or brutalised.  The serial sexual attacks on Andy, the prison guards' brutality, the violence, the murder of Tommy, the rejection of parole.

Macro-features - Narrative and Genre
The film belongs to the prison drama genre and its narrative is in line with its genre.  It tells the story of a wrongfully imprisoned man who undergoes a huge amount of brutal abuse, injustice and hardship yet manages to retain his sense of hope and ultimately escape to freedom and bring his corrupt captors to justice.

This narrative is inherently emotionally provocative as it taps into some very basic emotions and instinctive feelings - freedom, injustice, revenge.

The fact that it has a 'happy ending' is also relevant, especially when looked at in terms of its overall narrative structure.  The vast majority of the film is about the abuses and degradation Andy and his friends suffer as inmate os Shawshank Prison.  Although they win a few petty victories - the library, the beers on the roof etc, their life is one of misery and degradation which mounts and mounts.  This constant increasing of despair and hopelessness manipulates the spectator to feel enormous elation when the put upon hero is finally liberated and vindicated.

Representation
The representations of the characters and places within the film are an important part of how this film works to position the spectator to feel emotion.

The warden and guards are consistently represented as being corrupt, sadistic and completely unlikable.  This is exemplified in Warden Norton and Captain Hadley.  Norton is hypocritical, power-hungry, greedy, corrupt, selfish and ultimately murderous.  Hadley is similarly corrupt but is also violent, sadistic, hateful and foul-mouthed.  He wields his power even over the other guards.  The way they look, act, speak and are spoken to all reflect this very clearly.  They both dress meticulously and claim to have higher morals than others but are in fact criminals themselves.  Norton and Hadley are very clearly the 'villains' of the film.  There are a few more sympathetic guards seen but these are generally very sidelined and usually completely dominated by either Hadley or Norton.

The prisoners are, in contrast to this, very scruffy and worn.  They are represented in a very un-dangerous way.  They may be prisoners who have all committed terrible crimes but their representations make the spectator like them and feel sympathy for them.  They are likeable, kind (even to small animals), generous, and sympathetic.  The spectator is encouraged to identify with them.

The prison itself is represented as an incredibly bleak, grey and oppressive place.  Its thick stone walls are present in nearly every scene and gates and bars can be seen in every direction.  The lighting is often dark and oppressive inside and grey and bleak on the outside.

Spectator Alignment (Identification)
The spectator is constantly encouraged to sympathise and identify with Andy and Red. A large part of how this is done is through voice over.  The voice over is a technique which means that characters speak directly to the spectator thus putting them in the speaker's viewpoint much more firmly.  Everything we see in the film is through Red's eyes.  He tells us how to feel and how to think about many of the key moments in the film.

Close Analysis - Key Scene 1 - The Mozart Scene

Scene Summary:  The prison receives a large delivery of books and records due to Andy's persistent letter-writing.  Andy takes advantage of  the opportunity when he is briefly left alone by one of the softer  prison guards and locks himself in the warden's office.  He uses the tannoy system to broadcast a piece of classical music by Mozart to the entire prison.  Although he is punished severely for his actions all the inmates felt free for a fleeting moment of beauty.

Preferred reading:  The emotions of awed beauty, joy, happiness and triumph when Andy plays the music as well as fear of the reprisal he will face as a result.

Techniques Used to Provoke Emotion

Narrative structure:  The scene immediately before this one is one of the saddest moments in the film - Brooks' death.  We hear Brooks voice as he reads a letter he has written to Andy and Red accompanied by images of his life outside the prison and subsequent death by his own hand.  It is a pitiful, lonely and heart-breaking scene which leaves the spectator feeling very sad and 'down'.  This scene of rebellion and triumph gives the spectator an emotional tone shift and moment of relief.  The satisfaction and elation felt in this scene is keener due to the despair felt in the previous scene.

Cinematography/ Imagery:  Slow camera movements are used to great effect here as the prisoners stop what they are doing and look up at the speaker in awed silence and reverence.  The slow panning out of the camera as it looks down on the prison yard is especially effective as it shows the scale of the stunt and how even the wardens are shocked into silence and inactivity as a result of it.

Sound: The sound of the music itself gets louder throughout the scene and takes the place of nearly all over sound.  This encourages us to feel what the prisoners feel as they listen to the moving and beautiful music.  A voice over is again employed to anchor the meaning and add to it.

Performance:  Morgan Freeman's rich and sonorous tones add a huge amount of gravitas and feeling to the voice over dialogue.

Voice Over:  As with much of the film, this sequence use a voice over which aligns the spectator with Red's point of view.

Dialogue: "I have no idea to this day what those two Italian ladies were singing about. Truth is, I don't wanna know. Some things are best left unsaid. I'd like to think they were singing about something so beautiful it can't be expressed in words, and it makes your heart ache because of it. I tell you those voices soared, higher and farther than anybody in a grey place dares to dream. It was like some beautiful bird flapped into our drab little cage and made these walls dissolve away, and for the briefest of moments, every last man in Shawshank felt free."

Oppositional Reading:  Morgan Freeman's voice has become very distinctive since (and partly because of) this film.  Voice overs using his voice are particularly well known and it is almost a cliche for when a film wants to impart dramatic or emotional content.  This could cause a spectator to view the scene as overly-manipulative or too 'schmaltzy' or 'cheesy'.

Close Analysis - Key Scene 2


Scene Summary:  Andy returns to his cell after performing his usual routine having been released from solitary confinement after the incident with Tommy.  Red (and the audience) are very worried that Andy will kill himself in his cell that night.  In the morning, Andy has disappeared and it is revealed to the audience that he escaped in the night.

Preferred reading:  The intention of the scene is to make the spectator feel tension and anxiety which then turns to confusion and intrigue and finally turning to outright triumph, joy and satisfaction as the scene builds to its conclusion.

Techniques Used to Provoke Emotion

Narrative structure:  In the overall narrative of the film this scene occurs almost at the end.  Much of the film has shown the abuses and degradations suffered by Andy and the other prisoners with an escalating sense of severity and injustice.  This triumphant scene is made all the more satisfying as a result of this.  The scene itself is structured so that we worry that Andy has committed suicide as a result of all the terrible things that have happened to him.  Our sense of relief that this 'worst case scenario' has not happened increases our joy when we see that he has actually escaped.

Cinematography/ Imagery:  The tight, cramped shots of Andy in the sewer pipe covered in filth and excrement give a very apt visual metaphor for the abuses he has suffered and the journey he has ben forced to take.  The final shot of the scene of Andy, finally free - shirtless, washed clean by the rain in the dramatic lighting of the thunder storm is a powerful image and as the camera rises into an aerial shot and Andy looks up at the sky with his arms spread in an almost Christ-like pose the power is heightened.

Sound: The music effectively guides the spectator's emotions as it swells in an orchestral and moving piece of music.  Earlier in the scene, sound is used very effectively to give the impression of mystery as the warden throws a stone at the poster.  The stone rips through the poster and 'plinks' into the darkness beyond.  This is our first understanding of what has happened.

Performance:  The scene is anchored by Tim Robbins' immersive performance of Andy Dufresne.  Morgan freeman's voice performance is also a powerful emotive factor.

Voice Over:  Another Morgan Freeman voice over  - again it encourages the spectator to identify or align themselves with the character and the 'side' they are on. 

Year 12 Media - Case study: Slumdog Millionaire

Representation

How is India represented in Slumdog Millionaire?

1.  Division between wealth and poverty - seen in the train sequence.

2.  Religious conflict - seen when Jamal's mother is killed in the Hindu attack.

3.  Corruption in police force - seen when Jamal is tortured and when police don't help in the Hindu attack.

4.  Brutality and abuse of children - seen in the scene where the child is blinded.  Linked to extreme poverty.

5.  Strong community and culture - seen in scenes of crowds cheering for Jamal, the Bollywood dancing at the ending and the overall picture of India.

6.  Rich heritage - Taj Mahal sequence.

Sample Question

Using your own detailed examples, explore the representation of national identity in media texts.

Essay structure:

Introduce the concept.

Refer to 2-3 detailed examples; ensure you include technical analysis.

Conclude by summing up your points.

Year 12 Film Studies - Section C: US Film Comparison

 This unit is described in the WJEC exam board specification as follows:

"Section C: US Cinema Comparative Study (40 marks)
 One question from a choice of two.

Candidates are required to compare and contrast two films either from the same genre or dealing with a specific theme. 

Both questions will have an emphasis on the relationship between aspects of the films' narrative in relation to generic characteristics. 

The first question will be based primarily on narrative study. 

The second will be based on contextual study. 

Issues of representation will be common to both questions.

The films to be studied for this unit are:

The War of the Worlds (Byron Haskin 1953)

and 

The War of the Worlds (Steven Spielberg 2005)

Both films are adaptations of the novel by H.G Welles.

Year 12 Film Studies US Comparison SOW

AREAS OF STUDY
You must look at the following areas in relation to both of your focus films.  You will be looking for elements which are similar and different in these areas.

Representation

Social context

Messages and Values

Themes and Ideas

Setting and Place

Narrative/Genre


CLOSE ANALYSIS - The War of the Worlds (Byron Haskin

1953)

AIMS
To develop a critical understanding of the text.

To analyse the messages and values in the film.

To examine representation in the film.

To explore how significant setting and place is to the film’s themes.

To gain an understanding of the social context of the film.

Characters

Themes

Messages and Values

Key Scene 1 - The Ending

Representation

In order to analyse a representation you must ask yourself the following:

How do the characters look?  Costume? Make up? Facial expression?

How do they sound?  Voice?  Aural motifs/ soundtrack?  Diegetic sound design.

How do other people treat them?

Narrative – what happens to them?  What do they do?  What is their function in the narrative?

Setting and Place

Social Context

How does all of this affect the film's themes and messages and values?  Does the film uphold these ideas or challenge them?

CLOSE ANALYSIS - The War of the Worlds (Steven Spielberg 2005)

AIMS 
To develop a critical understanding of the text.

To analyse the messages and values in the film.

To examine representation in the film.

To explore how significant setting and place is to the film’s themes.

To gain an understanding of the social context of the film.

Characters

Themes

Messages and Values

Messages and values can often be identified most clearly in the endings of films.  Put simply, messages and values are what the film is saying is 'good' or 'right'.  What things (ideas, concepts, morals) are being celebrated and what are being denigrated?

Key Scene 1 - The Ending

Representation

Setting and Place

Social Context

Key Scene 2 - 

COMPARISONS BETWEEN THE TEXTS


The exam question will ask you to critically compare the two American films you have studied for this topic - The War of the Worlds.

The areas you must be able to discuss with thorough detail are:

Themes and Issues
Messages and Values
Representation of Gender/Age
Significance of Setting and Place
Wider Social Context
Narrative/Genre

ADVICE FROM THE EXAM BOARD

PAST QUESTIONS

With particular reference to the endings of your chosen American films, compare their messages and values.

How useful have your wider contextual studies been in understanding similarities and differences in the American films you have studied for this topic?

What is significant about setting and/or place in your chosen American films?

In the American films you have studied for this topic, how far do the representations of either women or men reflect the time when they were made?